Ah, The Broadfield. I have many memories of visits to this pub, five or six years ago. "The Broady", as it was often referred to, had two pool tables back then! Unfortunately that was all they had going for them. I stopped going when I moved away from nether edge, and frankly the thought of seeing the same old miserable, drunk faces didn't exactly lure me back.
Then I heard word of a brand new ownership and re-opening. To be honest I didn't even know it had closed down, I could say this was because I was no longer interested and had moved on etc. The likely truth is that I'm quite oblivious to what's going on around me most of the time that I simply didn't notice.
Eventually, curiosity got the better of me and I went down to investigate. Wow! I couldn't believe how much it had changed! It looks amazing inside. They've knocked down the walls so its one big massive pub with a huge circular bar in the middle, housing a massive selection of whiskeys. I recognise a few of the clientele, friendly, lovely nether edge folk. Not old, not twelve and not drunk. I even spot kid acne amongst the crowd! Then one of my favourite songs started playing and after that I noticed they serve cocktails, this all made me very happy to have a great pub to call my local.
That was my first visit. I went back again a few days later to sample their extensive menu. They serve a range of modern and exciting dishes such as : thai salmon goujons with a green papaya chili dip, moonshine battered haddock with chips, mushy peas and tartare sauce and spiced cauliflower fritters with tamarind dip. There is also a separate mini board for their various pies and sausages.
I eventually decided on smoked haddock and salmon kedgeree with poached egg. My mum chose beef and ale pie with chips and mushy peas.
After a small mishap with our waitress spilling some of my mums pint of cider, which was supposed to be only a 1/2 anyway (bonus!) onto our table, the service went smoothly.
Our food soon arrived. My first thoughts were "my god that is a lot of food" and "nice egg".
This was unlike any kedgeree I had eaten before. It was under seasoned, there was very little, if any spice at all, oh and the rice was the wrong type of rice! This was more like a risotto. At least they got the egg perfect though. On the plus side there were lots of chunks of fish, albeit some rather fatty pieces of salmon. I ended up eating the chunks of fish, plus the egg and leaving a massive pile of rice.
My mum ate hers with no complaints. I tried a chip and it was nice, home-made but not the best pub chips Sheffield has to offer.
The waitress didn't seemed too phased by our leftovers. Looking at a few plates on their way back to the kitchen I can see why. You definitely won't leave hungry after eating here. Unsatisfied, maybe but not hungry.
We decided to share a dessert and opted for the delicious sounding banana-chocolate brownie.
This was very squiggle happy presentation. I tried some sauce which was not that dissimilar from those "treats" squeezy ice cream sauce in bottles you can buy. Disappointing.
The praline under the ice cream was synthetic tasting, and the brownie itself wasn't bad, but the chunks of chewy - I'd have had no idea what the hell this was if it hadn't stated it on the menu - banana, were.
Overall, as a pub to come and have a drink, this is great. For food, I'd probably eat somewhere else.
Food 5.5/10
Service 7/10
Value 7/10